Skip to content
Schedule a Demo

On-demand workshop

Who leaves when your certificates renew?

Find the members most likely to leave at renewal, and stay competitive without raising every rate.

  • Recorded November 19, 2026
  • 25 min
  • Hosted by BlastPoint
Or scroll to read

Welcome

Chapter 1 of 7

All chapters

The short version

  1. About $453B in certificates comes due in the next 12 months at credit unions over $500M.

  2. At renewal, members with no checking left at 2.8%, vs 0.6% of members with checking.

  3. Skip matching every rate. Sort certificate-only members into three groups, and pay a better rate only to the low-fit, big-balance group. Matching everyone costs a typical $1B credit union about $490K a year.

Presenter

  • Tomer Borenstein

    Co-founder and CTO

Chapter 01What's coming due

Scene 01

About $453B in certificates comes due in the next 12 months

That's 24% of shares at credit unions over $500M. If 2.9% walks at renewal, about $13.1B leaves credit unions over $500M. The 2.9% is an estimate, not a forecast.

Source: NCUA call reports, Sept 30, 2026, preliminary. Non-IRA certificates with under a year left, 743 credit unions over $500M. Could walk is an estimate (2.9%), not a forecast.

Scene 02

Fewer credit unions are growing certificates faster than other deposits

The share of credit unions over $500M whose certificates grew faster than their other deposits went from 96% in 2023 to 83%, 71% and then 56% in 2026. Total certificate balances at all credit unions still rose, from $405B to $528B, $577B and $611B. Balances are still climbing, just slower.

Source: NCUA call reports, June 30 to Sept 30 each year, credit unions over $500M. 2026 preliminary. Balances: NCUA, all federally insured credit unions, June 30.

Scene 03

Where the $453B comes due

Credit unions between $2.5B and $10B hold the most certificates coming due: $188.1B across 189 credit unions. Next is $10B and up, with $143.9B across 26. Then $1B to $2.5B, with $81.7B across 254, and $500M to $1B, with $39.4B across 273.

Source: NCUA call reports, Sept 30, 2026, preliminary. Non-IRA certificates with under a year left.

Scene 04

Boosting every renewal by a quarter point could cost a typical $1B credit union about $490K a year

Match every rate and you overpay members who were renewing anyway. Match none, and certificate-only members take the deposits with them, right when replacing that funding costs the most.

Source: $196M renewing × 0.25 points, the median of the 72 credit unions with $0.9B to $1.1B in assets. NCUA call reports, Sept 30, 2026 (preliminary).

Chapter 02Who leaves at renewal

Scene 05

When a certificate matures, members with no checking are the ones who leave

2.8% of members with no checking left after their certificate matured, vs 0.6% of members with checking. Out of every 1,000 members whose certificate matured, that's 28 vs 6.

Source: BlastPoint platform data, pooled and anonymized, Oct 2026 snapshots. Left after maturity: six credit unions (155 leavers).

Scene 06

Myth: younger members don't have their direct deposit with you

38% of members under 35 have direct deposit at their credit union. So do 38% of members 55 and older. Before your next renewal batch, sort the list by direct deposit.

Source: BlastPoint platform data, pooled and anonymized, Oct 2026 snapshots. Direct deposit by age: 13 credit unions. Includes Social Security and pension deposits. Not an industry rate.

Scene 07

Every credit union has a few certificate holders. How many hold nothing else varies tenfold.

Certificate holders are 5% to 11% of members at all five credit unions. Of those certificate holders, 6% to 65% hold nothing besides the certificate and savings: 6%, 14%, 37%, 40% and 65%. Your renewal list won't look like anyone else's.

“Nothing else” means no product besides a certificate and savings. Source: BlastPoint platform data, five credit unions, Nov 18, 2026.

Chapter 03Who gets an offer

Scene 08

Three made-up members renewing in March: who gets an offer?

Pat holds only the certificate, so Pat gets one offer that fits. Lee's direct deposit stopped in the spring, so check in first. Sam holds everything and is likely renewing anyway.

Scene 09

Most certificate-only members may not fit checking. Many may fit another product, or a rate offer.

Of certificate-only members at one credit union, 89% score low for checking, 55% score low for checking and high for another product, and 25% hold $65K or more in their certificate. The 55% and the 25% can overlap. It is one credit union, so read it as “may”: a score shows fit, not who will open.

Source: one credit union on the BlastPoint platform, Nov 18, 2026. BlastPoint propensity scores, 1 to 10: low is 5 or under, high is over 5.

Chapter 04Your playbook

Scene 10

Each group gets its own move: a product, a better rate, or let it walk

One move per group, decided before the renewal notice goes out. Test each move against a holdout group before you count on it.

1. Good fit for another product: Offer that product. Lead the renewal call with it. No rate match. 2. Low fit, big balance: Offer a better rate. A targeted rate, only for this group. 3. Low fit, small balance: Let it walk. Standard renewal notice. No extra spend.

Cutoffs from one credit union on our platform: next-best-product score over 5 of 10, and $65K average certificate balance (about the top quarter). Set your own.

Scene 11

Before your next renewal batch

This replaces matching everyone: about $490K a year at a typical $1B credit union.

1. Pull your certificate-only list. Members whose certificate is all they have with you, besides savings. 2. Sort it into the three groups. Good fit for another product. Low fit, big balance. Low fit, small balance. 3. Pay for a better rate only for the big-balance group. Everyone else gets a product offer or the standard renewal notice.

Source: $196M renewing × 0.25 points, the median of the 72 credit unions with $0.9B to $1.1B in assets. NCUA call reports, Sept 30, 2026 (preliminary).

Scene 12

Five ideas to try on your own

All five are on the ideas board in the calculator.

Steal these ideas for your own playbook (opens in a new tab)

1. Sort the renewal list by direct deposit. Members with no checking and no direct deposit go to the top of the call list. 2. Watch for the paycheck that moves. Check in with members whose direct deposit stopped in the last 3 to 6 months. 3. Look at who already left. See what last year's non-renewed certificate holders held with you. 4. Ask about the household. On the renewal call, ask who else in the household banks elsewhere. 5. Set one goal with a date. For example, checking adoption among renewing members, checked every quarter.

Workshop companion

Take the calculator and retention ideas with you

The renewal-risk calculator and the ideas board from the workshop, in one place.

Open the CD Wall companion (opens in a new tab) Steal these ideas for your own playbook (opens in a new tab) Download the slides (PDF, asks for your work email once)

Next session

Grow Core Deposits and Members in 2027: Compare Plans With Growth Leaders at Peer Credit Unions

Wednesday, December 16, 1:00 p.m. ET. 60 minutes on Zoom.

Save your seat (opens in a new tab)